how to replace a cast iron toilet flange

Step-by-Step: Replacing a Cast Iron Toilet Flange

By Joseph Martin
AD

Are you dealing with a troublesome cast iron toilet flange that's causing leaks or preventing your toilet from sealing properly? Replacing it might seem daunting, but with the right steps and a bit of patient effort, you can tackle this task yourself. Our comprehensive guide will walk you through the process, from gathering your tools to ensuring a sturdy, leak-free seal.

Before we dive into the replacement process, let's understand why a cast iron flange might need replacing. These flanges, also known as closet flanges, can corrode or crack over time, leading to leaks or a loose fit. Additionally, if you're upgrading your toilet, you might need a new flange that's compatible with your new toilet's shape and size. Now, let's go through the process of replacing a cast iron toilet flange.

Preparation and Removal of the Old Flange

Before you start, gather your tools: an adjustable wrench, a hacksaw, a puttingty knife, a trowel, a new cast iron or plastic closet flange, and toilet wax rings or rubber gaskets. It's also helpful to have a bucket and towels or rags on hand to deal with any water spills.

AD
How to Replace a Cast Iron Toilet Flange in Concrete Simple Steps Explained
How to Replace a Cast Iron Toilet Flange in Concrete Simple Steps Explained
there is a hole in the floor with a spatula next to it
there is a hole in the floor with a spatula next to it
HOW TO REPAIR A CAST IRON TOILET FLANGE
HOW TO REPAIR A CAST IRON TOILET FLANGE

First, turn off the water supply valve located behind the toilet and flush the toilet to empty the tank. Use a sponge or towel to soak up any remaining water in the tank and bowl. Next, disconnect the water supply line from the bottom of the tank and carefully lift the tank off the bowl. Remember, the tank is heavy, so be cautious to avoid injury.

Removing the Old Flange

Now that the toilet is dismantled, you can reach the old flange. If it's difficult to access, you might need to remove the floor covering, such as vinyl or tile, around the toilet. Use the hacksaw to cut through any bolts or nails securing the flange in place. Wiggle the old flange to break the old wax seal, then use the adjustable wrench to remove it from the pipes.

Toilet Repair Ring Flange: Fix Leaks, Reset Your Toilet, and Stop a Running Toilet
Toilet Repair Ring Flange: Fix Leaks, Reset Your Toilet, and Stop a Running Toilet
How to Repair a Cast-Iron Toilet Flange | Ask This Old House
How to Repair a Cast-Iron Toilet Flange | Ask This Old House

If the old flange is deeply embedded in the floor or has a large ring on the bottom, you might need to use a reciprocating saw to cut the flange into pieces for easier removal. Don't worry about damaging the old flange; its purpose is to be replaced.

Preparing the Pipes for the New Flange

After removing the old flange, clean the pipe and floor to ensure a good seal for the new one. Use the putty knife to scrape away any old wax or debris, then wipe the area with a damp cloth. If there are any rough edges or sharp points on the pipes, smooth them out to prevent damaging the new wax ring.

AD

If your home has plastic pipes, you might want to use a plastic closet flange instead of cast iron. Plastic flanges can be easier to install and can compensate for slight variations in pipe height due to their flexibility. However, both cast iron and plastic flanges are suitable choices, so consider what's best for your specific situation.

Installing the New Flange and Toilet

With the old flange removed and the pipes cleaned, it's time to install the new one. If you're using a cast iron flange, apply a generous amount of plumber's putty around the bottom edge of the flange. This will create a watertight seal between the flange and the floor. If you're using a plastic flange, no putty is needed.

Center the new flange over the pipes, then press it firmly into place. If you're using cast iron, make sure the putty oozes out around the edges to create a good seal. Wipe away any excess putty with a damp cloth.

AD

Securing the Flange in Place

With the new flange in place, you can secure it to the floor using the existing bolts or by drilling new pilot holes. Make sure the bolts are long enough to go through the flange and the floor, then secure them with nuts and washers. Tighten the bolts gently, but don't over-tighten as this can damage the flange and create a weak seal. If you're using plastic bolts, use a Hancock nut to hold them in place securely.

Once the bolts are secured, you can attach the new toilet wax ring or rubber gasket. Center the ring on the bottom of the toilet and press gently to secure it in place. Make sure the ring covers the mounting bolts and completely fills the space between the toilet and the floor.

Reinstalling the Toilet

Now that the new flange is secure and the new wax ring is in place, it's time to reinstall the toilet. Carefully lower the toilet onto the bolts and settle it gently into place, making sure the bolts are completely covered by the toilet base. Install new bolt caps or washers and nuts, then tighten them just enough to secure the toilet in place.

AD

Reattach the water supply line to the tank and turn on the water supply valve. Check for any leaks around the toilet base and under the tank. If there are no leaks, you've successfully replaced your cast iron toilet flange.

Congratulations! You've just conquered a potentially tricky task and ensured a reliable, leak-free seal for your toilet. Regularly check your toilet connections to make sure everything is still secure and functioning as it should. If you ever face any issues, don't hesitate to seek professional help. Happy DIYing!

AD