How to Spot Real Ivory: A Guide to Telling Ivory from Resin
Distinguishing real ivory from its numerous synthetic counterparts, such as resin, is a critical skill for enthusiasts, collectors, and those involved in the responsible trade of vintage or antique items. Not only does accurate identification help preserve endangered elephant populations, but it also safeguards you from legal and ethical dilemmas. Learning how to tell real ivory from resin involves a combination of understanding the properties of the materials, examining objects closely, and using simple tests.
In modern times, resin has become the primary substitute for ivory. It's easier to acquire, less controversial, and often more affordable. Yet, it's crucial to remember that neither real ivory nor resin is a perfect substitute for the other. Each has distinct characteristics that set them apart. This guide explores the ins and outs of discerning real ivory from resin, ensuring you make well-informed decisions.
Understanding the Materials: Ivory vs. Resin
Before delving into identification techniques, let's first explore the unique characteristics of real ivory and resin.
Ivory is derived from the teeth and tusks of mammals, primarily elephants. It's an organic material composed of crystalline structures of calcium carbonate known as calcite. This makes it difícil for it to take on any color other than what can be applied through staining or dyeing. Additionally, genuine ivory has a distinct warm, natural tone.
Real Ivory's Textures and Patterns
Real ivory exhibits distinct markings and patterns. The most common is Schreger's lines, a crisscross pattern near the outer edge of elephant ivory. These lines are a result of growth rings in the tusk. Furthermore, real ivory might show distinctive growth rings when viewed end on. These growth rings may show swirls and ripples, giving ivory a unique, natural beauty.
Other animals' ivories, such as mammoth tusks, also display these growth rings, but they tend to be more wavy and less regular than those in elephant ivory. Moreover, mammoth ivory can range in color from cream to dark yellow or brown, sometimes with a reddish hue or even tiger striping - dark stripes against a lighter background.
Resin's Varieties and Characteristics
Resin, on the other hand, is a synthetic material produced by several plant species for various purposes, such as protection from pathogens, herbivory, and for attracting pollinators. In commerce, it's used as a substitute for natural materials, including ivory. Resin typically mimics the look and feel of ivory quite well, but it lacks the unique textures and patterns found in real ivory.
Resin is produced in large quantities and can be dyed to mimic the appearance of ivory. However, some resins, such as Celluloid and Tuskoid, are older and may not have been dyed. These older resins often have a distinct orange or yellow hue. Moreover, some newer resins might not accurately replicate the density, warmth, and translucence of real ivory, again depending on their composition and quality.
Inspecting the Object: Visual and Tactile Characteristics
Closely examining an object can provide valuable insights into whether it's made of real ivory or resin. A critical first step is to observe the item's color, shininess, and presence of any identifying marks or features.
In the early 20th century, the Convention for the International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) required that all new ivory products be inscribed with a unique identification number. If the item you're examining has one of these lot numbers, it's likely to be made of ivory. However, absence of these numbers doesn't necessarily mean the item is made of resin.
Observing the Color, Shine, and Warmth
Real ivory has a warm, natural tone due to its calcium carbonate composition. It may appear slightly translucent when held to the light, especially at the edges. It also undergoes a phenomenon called 'ambering,' where prolonged exposure to light causes the ivory to darken. Thisprocess can take several decades, with high-quality ivory slowly developing a honey, amber, or reddish tinge over time.
By contrast, resin tends to be cool to the touch and often has a consistent, uniform color. It doesn't amber over time and doesn't exhibit the same translucency as real ivory. Moreover, cheaper imitations might have a slightly 'glossy' reflectiveness, which genuine ivory doesn't possess.
Checking for the[item's flexibility and density](https://www.britannica.com/science/calcium-carbonate#/media/381359/52425792 "Checking for the item's flexibility and density.")
Genuine ivory is rigid and has a specific gravity of approximately 1.8. It's heavier than water and will sink in a glass of water. When struck, it will produce a distinct, resonant tone, like a piano key. If you're suspicious about an item and have access to another known piece of ivory, you can compare their weights and sounds.
Resin, however, is lighter and easier to cut than real ivory. High-quality imitation ivories can be quite convincing, but they're generally easier to scratch or bend than genuine ivory. Additionally, resin won't produce the same resonant sound as real ivory when struck.
Performing Simple Tests
Besides examining the object visually and tactilely, some simple tests can help confirm if an item is made of genuine ivory or resin. These tests involve painting, UV light, water, and vinegar.
However, it's essential to remember that these tests aren't foolproof, and they might not work with all samples. High-quality imitations may pass some or all of these tests, and some genuine ivories, due to their age or treatment, might not respond as expected. Furthermore, these tests can potentially damage the object or art piece, particularly if it's of significant value. It's always recommended to consult with a professional or an expert in the field before performing any tests.
Testing with Paint
One simple test involves using a permanent marker or a spot of nail polish. Apply a small amount to an inconspicuous area of the object. True ivory, being porous, will absorb the ink quickly and permanently. Resin, being non-porous, will not absorb the ink, and it can typically be wiped off easily.
Another test involves applying a drop of warm vinegar. Real ivory will fizz and bubble on contact with the acid, whereas ivory replacements typically won't react. However, this test can be destructive and isn't recommended for valuable items.
Using UV Light for Identification
Using a UV light or black light can sometimes help identify genuine ivory. A small portion of actual ivory glows blue under UV light, while resin doesn't fluoresce. However, many Agustín peces of ivory and ivory replacements today have been treated with chemicals that make them fluoresce under UV light, so this test is not always reliable.
Another approach is using a UV-LED flashlight, which emits both visible and ultraviolet light. When held at an angle to the object, this light can reveal hidden markings, such as watermarks or processing codes, which may not be visible under ordinary light.
Understanding the differences between real ivory and resin is not only crucial for ethical and conservation reasons but also to ensure you're acquiring or trading authentic, high-quality items. Whether you're an avid collector, a seasoned antique dealer, or simply curious, knowing how to tell real ivory from resin empowers you to make informed decisions and participate responsibly in the global marketplace.