how to fight a mechanics lien in florida

How to Fight a Mechanic's Lien in Florida: Step-by-Step Guide

By Melissa Taylor
AD

Facing a mechanics lien in Florida? You're not alone. This legal tool, used by contractors and subcontractors to secure payment, can be a real headache. But don't despair; understanding the lien process and knowing your rights can help you fight back. Let's dive into how to combat a mechanics lien in the Sunshine State.

First, it's crucial to understand that Florida is a lien theory state, which means contractors have an automatic lien on the property for the labor and materials provided. However, this doesn't mean you're helpless. There are steps you can take to protect your interests. Let's explore your options.

Understanding the Liens Process

before you start fighting, it's essential to understand how a mechanics lien works in Florida.

AD
How to file mechanics liens in 5 steps
How to file mechanics liens in 5 steps
How to Find Out if a Car Has a Lien on It | YourMechanic Advice
How to Find Out if a Car Has a Lien on It | YourMechanic Advice
Free Mechanic's Lien Waiver Template: Sample & FAQs
Free Mechanic's Lien Waiver Template: Sample & FAQs

The process begins when a contractor files a claim of lien on the property. This notice informs the property owner and other interested parties about the unpaid amount. The lien attaches to the property, not the owner's personal assets, but it can complicate things like selling or refinancing the property.

vencible and non-vencible Liens

Familiarize yourself with the two types of mechanics liens in Florida - valid and invalid.

Mechanics Lien 2 | Pdf Fpdf Doc Docx | Business Forms
Mechanics Lien 2 | Pdf Fpdf Doc Docx | Business Forms
Property Lien(aka Mechanics Lien): What Is It And How To Avoid It + Release Of Lien Form
Property Lien(aka Mechanics Lien): What Is It And How To Avoid It + Release Of Lien Form

A valid lien is filed by a contractor who has complied with all the legal requirements, while an invalid lien might be filed by a dishonest contractor or one who has breached their contract with you. Understanding the distinction can help you determine whether to fight the lien or negotiate with the contractor.

When is the Lien Filed?

The timeline of the lien filing can also provide clues about its validity. In Florida, a claim of lien must be filed within 90 days of the last labor or material provided. If the lien is filed after this deadline, it may be invalid.

AD

Furthermore, the contractor has 120 days from the date of the lien to file a lawsuit to enforce it. If they miss this deadline, the lien becomes unenforceable, and you can request its removal.

Options for Fighting a Mechanics Lien in Florida

Once you've gathered information about the lien, it's time to decide how to proceed. Here are your options:

Request a Lien Waiver

A lien waiver is a legal document that releases your property from the lien once you've paid the contractor. If you believe the lien is valid but want to clear it as soon as possible, negotiating a lien waiver might be the best course of action.

AD

However, ensure you're comfortable with the terms of the waiver and that it's legally binding. Consult with a legal professional if needed.

Challenge the Lien

If you believe the lien is invalid or has been improperly filed, you can challenge it by filing a response to the claim of lien. This response must be filed within 20 days of receiving the notice of the lien.

In your response, you can assert any defenses you have, such as non-payment due to poor workmanship or completed work that didn't meet your agreed-upon standards. You can also request a jury trial to resolve the dispute.

AD

File a Motion to Dismiss

After filing a response to the claim of lien, you can also file a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. This motion should be based on a legal argument, such as a lack of jurisdiction or improper service of the claim of lien.

If successful, the motion to dismiss will result in the lien being removed from your property. However, it's essential to consult with a legal professional before attempting this strategy.

Lastly, remember that fighting a mechanics lien can be complex, and the process can vary depending on your specific circumstances. Consider seeking legal advice if you're unsure about any aspect of the procedure. Acting promptly and understanding your rights can make all the difference in protecting your property and your investment.

AD