1935 buffalo nickel double die reverse how to tell

1935 Buffalo Nickel Double Die Reverse: Expert Tips to Identify

By Richard Smith
AD

If you're a numismatist or coin collector, you've likely heard about the enigmatic "1935 Buffalo Nickel Double Die Reverse." This controversial coin has sparked debates among collectors and experts alike, with some arguing its authenticity while others dismiss it as a hoax. In this comprehensive guide, we'll delve into the world of this intriguing coin, explaining what makes it unique, how to identify it, and addressing the surrounding controversies.

Before we dive into the specifics, let's set the stage. The Buffalo Nickel, or Indian Head Nickel, was minted from 1913 to 1938. The 1935 version is distinct due to its rumored double die reverse variety. Now, let's explore the key aspects of this coin.

Understanding the 1935 Buffalo Nickel

The 1935 Buffalo Nickel is an intriguing coin due to its sheer volume of production. Mints in Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco produced approximately 335 million pieces in 1935, making it plentiful in circulated grades. However, the attraction lies in its rare variety, the Double Die Reverse.

AD
an old silver buffalo coin with the word five cents below it and a red arrow pointing up
an old silver buffalo coin with the word five cents below it and a red arrow pointing up
1935 Buffalo Nickel Error Doubled Die Reverse / DDR - Coin Community Forum
1935 Buffalo Nickel Error Doubled Die Reverse / DDR - Coin Community Forum
Images of Buffalo Nickel 1935 5C Doubled Die Reverse - PCGS CoinFacts
Images of Buffalo Nickel 1935 5C Doubled Die Reverse - PCGS CoinFacts

Die varieties are not scarce in coinage history, but a double die error is quite rare. A double die occurs when a die is improperly wiped or cleaned and is struck twice, resulting in a mirror image of the design's details on the coin.

Identifying the Double Die Reverse

Identifying a 1935 Buffalo Nickel Double Die Reverse involves a keen eye for detail. The error is most visible on the reverse (the back of the coin), specifically on the words "FIVE CENTS." The "C" and "S" in "CENTS" will appear double-struck, with one reversed image "."

How Much Is A 1935 Buffalo Nickel Worth?
How Much Is A 1935 Buffalo Nickel Worth?
1935 P Buffalo Nickels Doubled Die Reverse Indian Head Nickel - Line Type
1935 P Buffalo Nickels Doubled Die Reverse Indian Head Nickel - Line Type

To confirm the double die error, you can use a magnifying glass or a loupe to examine the coin's reverse. You can also try the "ուրա" test, where you hold the coin under a bright light and tilt it at an angle. If the error is present, you should see two "C" and two "S" images.

Grading the 1935 Buffalo Nickel Double Die Reverse

Grading a double die error involves determining the severity of the doubling. A coin with light doubling may be graded as a "weak" or "light" double die, while one with heavy doubling might be a "strong" or "heavy" double die. Coins with partial doubling or just a single letter doubled might be considered "partial" double dies.

AD

The key to proper grading is understanding that the severity of the doubling doesn't necessarily determine the coin's value. A "weak" double die with a clean strike and well-preserved Mint State surfaces can be worth more than a "heavy" double die with bag marks or other issues.

Controversy and Skepticism Surrounding the 1935 Double Die Reverse

While many collectors eagerly pursue the 1935 Buffalo Nickel Double Die Reverse, not everyone is convinced of its authenticity. Critics argue that some supposed double dies are merely die marks or normal die variations, not genuine errors. Others point to the large number of fakes and altered coins in circulation, which can make finding an authentic specimen challenging.

The controversy has led to numerous studies and investigations by coin authentication services and experts. Some have concluded that genuine 1935 Buffalo Nickel double dies do exist, while others remain skeptical.

AD

Debunking Misconceptions About the 1935 Double Die Reverse

One common misconception is that all 1935 Buffalo Nickels are worth a fortune because of the double die error. The truth is, only those with the double die reverse error are valuable, and even then, the coin's worth depends on its grade and strike.

Another misconception is that all 1935 Buffalo Nickels with a double image on the "C" and "S" are genuine double dies. Unfortunately, this isn't always the case. Some coins might have die marks or normally occurring die varieties that mimic a double die.

As with any rare and valuable coin, the key to owning a genuine 1935 Buffalo Nickel Double Die Reverse lies in thorough research, education, and careful examination by a trusted coin grading service or expert.

AD

The allure of the 1935 Buffalo Nickel Double Die Reverse is undeniable, drawing collectors into a world of intrigue and mystery. Whether you're a seasoned numismatist or a curious beginner, understanding this captivating coin can enrich your collecting journey. Happy hunting!

AD